Thursday, 12 April 2007

SAT Question of the Day

What are the oxidation numbers for In and Pb in the following compounds: InCl2 and Pb2O3?
(A) In = 2, Pb = 3
(B) In = 1, Pb = 3
(C) In = 2, Pb = 4
(D) In = 2, Pb = 2
(E) None of the above;

32 comments:

Anonymous said...

A

Anonymous said...

i got A too

Blog owner said...

Think once more.

Anonymous said...

is it c then ?

Anonymous said...

Oxidation numbers for Pb in Pb2O3 is 2 and 4(PbO*PbO2)and for In is2 inInCl2.

Blog owner said...

None of the answers are right.Please post your answers.

Anonymous said...

d ?

Anonymous said...

-_-... what's the answer then?

charlie said...

B
Try to balance the equation. Cl is 1- and 0 is 2-

Blog owner said...

The correct answer is E.
For the metals in the lower part of groups 3-6 A, their is a tendency to form compounds with the valence x and x -2 where is x is the group number;
EX: Pb group 4 valences 2 and 4
In group 3 valences 3 and 1
Therefore when they aggregate together we have:
Pb2O3 a mixture of PbO and PbO2
InCl2 a mixture of InCl3 and InCl which can be written as In2Cl4- or InCl2[this is very confusing but if you checked the position of In in the periodical system you would have seen that it can not have valence 2]

Blog owner said...

So the oxidation number are Pb 2 and 4 and In 1 and 3

Anonymous said...

Is this a problem that could appear at SAT chemistry? Isn't it too hard for this type of exam?

Anonymous said...

yea..his question of the day's are supposed to be harder than the average SAT chemistry question

Anonymous said...

this problem would never appear on a chemistry SAT test and if it would the correct answer would be A. According to the rules regarding oxidation numbers which I have learned in my own chemistry class, as well as barrons, sparknotes, and PR, you are to suppose that in a compound oxygen has an oxidation number of 2- and the halogens have an oxidation number of 1-. Therefore, with some simple math, the answer would be A. I'm sure the blog owner is correct, but going that indepth will end up hurting you on the SAT because the test-makers oversimplify everything . Plus I don't think none of the above is ever an answer on the SAT subject test.

Anonymous said...

it IS august 15th, 2007. hope to see your site back up soon. i really like the sat questions of the day. thanks a mucho :]
lovepeacehappyness

Anthony T said...

The blogowner is right. Indium and Thallium only forms compounds with O.S. number of +1 and +3

So, for InCl2, the actual formula would be In2Cl4, or In+1 and [InCl4]-, with the second In having +3 OS state.

Lead only forms compounds with +2 and +4 Os state (+2 is prefered).


The question is, this is supposed to be something you learn in an advanced inorganic chemistry, not in highschool..I think.

So, for SAT, I wonder if we can just answer A, or E...

marah said...

the answer is E..because In +3 and Pb is +2...

Anonymous said...

its A .
Cl has a -1 charge. therefore In must have a +2 charge to balance the compound.

Pb2O3--> O has a -2 oxidation number and thus comes out to -6. to balance this Pb must be +3

Anonymous said...

and this is an extremely easy type of problem compared to the ones ive been doing in the barrons chem sat book..

Anonymous said...

the thing is ^^^
youre right if you follow oxudation rules.. however if the compounds are ions you have to take into account the ionic charge of each compound and thus you wouldnt balance the oxidation numbers to ). you would balance them to equal their ionic charge which wasnt given.

Anonymous said...

It is A

Anonymous said...

This post reminds me about the old days of good blogging. If you can please visit my site [url=http://kitchencheap.co.uk/]kitchen cheap[/url]

Anonymous said...

t's such a great site. fanciful, very stimulating!!!

-------

[url=http://oponymozgowe.pl]Opony Mozgowe[/url]
[url=http://pozycjonowanie.lagata.pl]Pozycjonowanie[/url]

[url=http://vitria.pl/zdrowie,i,uroda/opony,s,1969/]opony[/url]

Anonymous said...

Nice to see you back. And again by having an interesting post.financial help

Anonymous said...

This article was extremely interesting.financial help for college

Anonymous said...

Chattyeffothe
[url=http://healthplusrx.com/msm-macular-edema]msm macular edema[/url]
exhagsnex

Anonymous said...

I couldn t agree more! good job! financial help

financial help

Anonymous said...

do i take a auto insurance provider to small claims court? The insurance company turned down my claim, (I would take the to blame driver to small claims though I've no address to serve them or send a requirement letter). Another driver was at fault however his particular insurance firm states that there may be a difference with our statements so they need to take the word of their insured vs. my word. I do think they acted in negative belief and did not execute a proper investigation would this become a valid claim in small claims court? I want to use the responsible drivers insurance company (not my own) to small claims for the damages to my car.

Anonymous said...

Unfortunatly my truck was recently broke into and someone stole my whole workout bag.. needless to say I had to buy some new [url=http://www.hotyogadeals.com] [b][i]hot yoga[/i][/b] [/url] gear.. The prices and shipping over at hotyogadeals.com were amazing, everything is backed by amazon too incase I need help with anything.

Anonymous said...

Bu sohbet sitesi tek kelimeyle Muhtes. Sohbet Etmek ve Arkadas, Olmak için Arad? Seçmenin Faydalar?

Anonymous said...

A is the choice....

Anonymous said...

The answer: A. you have In and Cl2 and so Cl has an oxidation number of -1x2 (for the 2 molecules bount to In) so, in order to make the charges even out, In must have an oxidation number of +2. therefore +2, and -2 = 0. And for Pb2O3. Oxygen has an oxidation number of (-2) (a fact you would have to know). So, we take that number and multiply it by the number of molecules (3). getting -6. And so in order to balance that with the pb2, which means two molecules, we have 2(x) (x is the unknown oxidation number) -6 = 0, so x = +3. There you are!